Global Young Academy releases report on challenges facing young scholars

Guest Contributor
March 13, 2014

A new organization representing young scholars around the world has released a baseline report that seeks to quantify the challenges facing early-career researchers once they receive their PhDs. Produced by the Global Young Academy (GYA), the report assesses the global knowledge on the state of young researchers in developed and developing nations and makes recommendations on ways to improve their working environments and opportunities for career advancement.

Entitled The Global State of Young Scientists (GloSYS), the 66-page report was released in Berlin in January and makes six recommendations addressing issues such as lack of resources and improving life-work balance to ensuring academic freedom and developing a culture of mentoring (see chart). The report is illuminating both for the commonalities and stark contrasts it finds across jurisdictions, particularly between North American and European nations and those of Africa, Asia and parts of the Middle East and Latin America.

"This is our first high-profile effort. It's a precursor study and the starting point is to quantify and start the conversation at all levels by looking at the best ways to support early-career researchers as they move toward independence," says Dr Reese Kassen, GYA's co-chair and a professor of experimental evolution at the Univ of Ottawa. "The next phase will be to dig deeper into regional issues. For example, the motivation for young researchers in the developed world is doing the research and creating ideas whereas in Africa it tends to be giving back to the country and society."

Since its inception in 2010 in Berlin, GYA has grown to its maximum membership of 200, representing 64 countries in all regions of the world. The GloSYS report was funded by the German Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) with contributions from the Inter Academy Panel and the Volkswagen Foundation. Young scholars are defined as researchers within 10 years of obtaining their PhDs and typically 30-40 years of age. Their academic career point (from a North American perspective) is between assistant and associate professor status.

Kassen notes that the strong idealistic notions of young researchers are often not supported in the most effective ways. Most spend many hours on teaching and administrative duties, squeezing their time available for research. Long hours also cut into private life, particularly those trying to raise young families.

"We're experiencing profound changes in the nature of families and the challenges are very real but they often aren't recognized by senior people in our profession," says Kassen. "There are also regional disparities. Many African nations tend to be very old school in attitudes towards women in the workplace and gender diversity."

Disparities abound in other areas as well. In Germany, 80% of young scholars are concerned about finding permanent employment while in many countries of the Middle East, top-of-mind concerns are often political instability and war.

The report identified mentorship is another key challenge. While it varies widely from country to country, all recognize that it's hard to manage. It also examines gender disparity and mobility — a key touchstone as technology increases the ease with which researchers can work and collaborate with colleagues regardless of location.

Global Young Academy

Co-Chairs

Sameh Soror

Helwan Univ

Egypt

Rees Kassen

Univ of Ottawa

Canada

GloSYS report authors

Irene Friesenhahn

Germany

Catherine Beaudry

Polytechnique Montreal

Canada

GYA membership is currently overwhelmingly academic but efforts are being made to expand into other areas to support career aspirations in industry, government and elsewhere.

In Canada, the recent creation of the College of New Scholars, Artists and Scientists may provide a forum for addressing the challenges of young researchers. A branch of the Royal Society of Canada, the college's first cohort of members will be in place later this year (R$, December 18/13) and Kassen says it could be a valuable tool for achieving the objectives of the GYA.

FMI: www.globalyoungacademy.net

R$

GloSYS Recommendations

Address the lack of resources, whether material or personnel, and the lack of funding for young scientists across regions of the world. Could be achieved by pooling resources across and within regions, by building inventories of available resources and providing sharing agreements between institutions.

Develop a nurturing culture aimed at providing better and more appropriate mentoring and supervision at all levels of early career, from PhD to the first 5–10 years of academic independence and beyond. This includes professional skills for master and doctoral students that may not want to remain in academia and for young researchers that may want to diversify their career interests.

Provide means for scholars and researchers to achieve a better work-life balance. Research organizations need to adapt to the realities of women and family issues. The long working hours researchers feel pressured to put in are often incompatible with proper work-life balance. The average scholar works more than 50 hours per week.

Value all aspects of the academic profession and don't expect scholars to excel at everything. A diversity of skills should be reintroduced and valued within organizations.

Ensure academic freedom while maintaining a healthy balance between basic and applied research in the portfolio of national and international funding programs. Blue-sky research is typically the only way to supply ideas for an innovation pipeline but may not have immediate impacts. Developing more appropriate measures of impact, beyond the current bibliometric obsession, is crucial to insure proper incentives. The fragile equilibrium between blue-sky and more applied research needs to be maintained.

Encourage and perform further studies on young scholars globally so institutions can learn from best practices in other regions while accounting for various research systems. The GloSYS team is ready to work alongside large research groups interested in the study of science and researchers, while keeping a focus on young scholars and under-researched regions.



Other News






Events For Leaders in
Science, Tech, Innovation, and Policy


Discuss and learn from those in the know at our virtual and in-person events.



See Upcoming Events










You have 1 free article remaining.
Don't miss out - start your free trial today.

Start your FREE trial    Already a member? Log in






Top

By using this website, you agree to our use of cookies. We use cookies to provide you with a great experience and to help our website run effectively in accordance with our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.