Corporate R&D outlays pulled down in 2010 by Nortel and TELUS, new data show

Guest Contributor
November 11, 2011

Spectacular declines by TELUS Corp and the now-defunct Nortel Networks Corp led to the worst drop in corporate R&D spending in recent memory as Canada's Top 100 R&D-performing firms posted $9.64 billion in outlays, a 9.4% decline over 2009 when $10.4 billion was spent. Half of the companies on the list posted lower R&D outlays, the highest number of decliners in years.

The discouraging corporate R&D performance comes despite an increase in overall revenues of nearly 5%. The current downturn could push R&D outlays down even further in 2011.

TELUS and Nortel posted drops of 81% and 87.3% respectively but when taken out of the mix, the remaining 98 firms posted a collective 3.5% gain powered by major increases from Ericsson Canada Inc (79.2%) and #1-ranked Research In Motion Ltd (26.3%).

RIM's $1.4 billion R&D tally marks the second year in a row that the Waterloo ON-based manufacturer of the Blackberry line of smart phones has topped the list. With $20.5 billion in annual revenue, the company posted a healthy 6.8% in research intensity (R&D as a percentage of revenue).

In 2009, TELUS posted the greatest gain of all Top 100 companies (211%), vaulting from 11th to 4th place. The 2010 performance of the Vancouver-based telecommunications services firm saw R&D outlays plunge from $653 million to $124 million for a #16 ranking, tied with competitor Rogers Communications Inc. The major player in the telecommunications services sector — BCE Inc — boosting its R&D by 1.9% and moved from 3rd to 2nd place with R&D expenditures of $821 million.

The Top 100 Corporate R&D Spenders ranking is produced by Research Infosource, a sister firm to RE$EARCH MONEY.

Despite the less-than-stellar results of this year's ranking, the Top 100 list contains a healthy mix of sectors in which R&D is a driving force. The Top 10 alone has representation from seven sectors including automotive (Magna International Inc), aerospace (Pratt & Whitney Canada Corp, Bombardier Inc) and electronic systems and parts (AMD Canada).

Communications and telecom equipment companies are the single largest R&D-spending sector, with 12 firms racking up $2.42 billion in R&D for 26% of the Top 100 total. While no firms in the pharmaceutical and biotechnology (P&B) sector made the top 10, there are 26 firms placed in the Top 100, spending $1.47 billion or 16% of the total. Of the 10 most research-intensive firms, seven come from the P&B sector.

Of the top 10 firms by growth, only one is from the P&B sector, while half of the firms posting the largest declines in R&D spending are P&B.

The only research-intensive firm from the upper tier of corporate R&D spending is Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd. The crown corporation recently privatized its nuclear reactor products division and boosted its R&D expenditures in 2010 by 21.2% to $476 million.

In 2010, 22 companies spent in excess of $100 million on R&D, 14 of which are Canadian owned. Cumulatively, these firms spent $6.67 billion on R&D, down 13.1% from the year before. When Nortel and TELUS are omitted, however, the remaining 20 firms posted a 4.5% increase in R&D spending.

Ontario was home to Ontario 45 of Top 100 firms, followed by Quebec (27), British Columbia (13) and the Prairies (14).

R$

Canada's Top 100 Corporate R&D Spenders 2011

($000s)
R&D Expenditures         Research   
20102009Company FY2010   FY2009   % ChangeRevenue   Intensity   
11Research In Motion Ltd*$1,391,395   $1,101,848   26.3   $20,502,219   6.8   
23BCE Inc.$821,000   $806,000   1.9   $18,069,000   4.5   
35IBM Canada Ltd (fs)$551,100   $556,500   -1.0   nd      
48Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd$476,400   $393,051   21.2   $460,935   103.4   
56Magna International Inc*$463,455   $553,870   -16.3   $24,142,916   1.9   
67Pratt & Whitney Canada Corp (fs)$395,000   $398,000   -0.8   $2,912,000   13.6   
710Ericsson Canada Inc (fs)$353,000   $197,000   79.2   $1,004,000   35.2   
8AMD Canada (fs)$241,694   $252,612   -4.3   nd      
99Alcatel-Lucent (fs)$233,000   $224,000   4.0   nd      
1014Bombardier Inc*$198,771   $161,022   23.4   $18,241,589   1.1   
1111Apotex Inc$178,852   $188,773   -5.3   $1,216,780   14.7   
1212Sanofi (fs) $159,182   $181,621   -12.4   $609,910   26.1   
1321Pfizer Canada Inc (fs)$145,488   $109,378   33.0   $1,972,224   7.4   
1417Open Text Corp*$133,246   $132,659   0.4   $939,292   14.2   
1519Ontario Power Generation Inc$127,000   $112,000   13.4   $5,375,000   2.4   
1628Rogers Communications Inc$124,000   $81,000   53.1   $12,186,000   1.0   
164TELUS Corp$124,000   $653,000   -81.0   $9,779,000   1.3   
1815GlaxoSmithKline Canada (fs)$120,949   $147,813   -18.2   $1,089,628   11.1   
1918CAE Inc$116,951   $121,647   -3.9   $1,526,300   7.7   
202Nortel Networks Corp*$110,199   $864,494   -87.3   $638,538   17.3   
2125Imperial Oil Ltd$107,000   $89,000   20.2   $24,946,000   0.4   
2222Hydro-Québec$100,000   $100,000   0.0   $12,338,000   0.8   
2320Novartis Pharmaceuticals Canada Inc (fs)$98,000   $110,000   -10.9   nd      
2424Sierra Wireless, Inc*$92,861   $94,662   -1.9   $669,786   13.9   
2530Constellation Software Inc*$87,418   $74,952   16.6   $649,720   13.5   
* Converted to Cdn at annual average 2010 = $1.0299, 2009 = $1.1420; (fs) - foreign subsidiary; nd not disclosed
Source: Research Infosource



Other stories mentioning these organizations, people and topics

Other News






Events For Leaders in
Science, Tech, Innovation, and Policy


Discuss and learn from those in the know at our virtual and in-person events.



See Upcoming Events










You have 1 free article remaining.
Don't miss out - start your free trial today.

Start your FREE trial    Already a member? Log in






Top

By using this website, you agree to our use of cookies. We use cookies to provide you with a great experience and to help our website run effectively in accordance with our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.