Canada's ranking in WEF global competitiveness index continues to fall

Guest Contributor
September 20, 2012

Innovation expert questions report's value

Canada has slipped another two positions on the ranking of global economic competitiveness published annually by the World Economic Forum (WEF). The massive report that compiles information from 144 countries says Canada is "being dragged down" by the quality of its research institutions and the government's role in "promoting innovation through procurement policies", compounded by lower university enrollment rates and less than sufficient training of academic staff.

The Conference Board of Canada is the WEF's Canadian partner on the report, which offers few details or analysis to back its observations on Canada or the types of people contacted for the survey. That's a problem, says a leading expert on Canadian innovation who questions the veracity of the report.

Dr Richard Hawkins says the report section on innovation is heavily slanted towards S&T investment with little consideration given to other important factors such as pricing, business models, supply chains and product processes.

"The knowledge contribution of the report is zero. It does not contribute to a better understanding of Canadian innovation," says Hawkins, a professor and Canada Research Chair in science, technology and innovation at the Univ of Calgary. "Science is a success story in Canada, with a modest investment and high impact. Value creation is the key indicator and this report doesn't indicate anything."

The report concludes that the most problematic factor for doing business in Canada is an inefficient government bureaucracy — a factor Hawkins notes is in the top three of most countries.

As for the second biggest problem facing business — inefficient capacity to innovate — Hawkins says there's precious little to substantiate the conclusion.

"I don't know what they mean by that. One of the problems with this report is its old-fashioned approach. It divides the world up into five or six categories where it assumes the economy is being driven by a set of factors. It ignores 50 years of rigorous study that shows it's not that simple," he says. "

Hawkins says Canada appears to be in the middle of the pack as an innovative nation, which is reasonable considering the country's size and natural resource wealth. But by including some measures and not others, an incomplete picture emerges.

"This report only looks at capital investment and concludes that there's insufficient capacity to innovate. I really don't know what they (WEF) means by that," he says. "If you strike a median instead of a mean, it's a completely different picture. About 35 countries account for 95% of the world's innovation. It's highly skewed data."

The WEF report bases its ranking on 12 so-called pillars of competitiveness: institutions, infrastructure, macroeconomic environment, health and primary education, higher education and training, goods market efficiency, labour market efficiency, financial market development, technological readiness, market size, business sophistication and innovation.

WEF Global
Competitiveness Ranking

CountryFY12-13FY11-12
Switzerland1   1   
Singapore2   2   
Finland3   4   
Sweden4   3   
Netherlands5   7   
Germany6   6   
United States7   5   
United Kingdom8   10   
Hong Kong9   11   
Japan10   9   
Qatar11   14   
Denmark12   8   
Taiwan/China13   13   
Canada14   12   
Norway15   16   
Austria16   19   
Belgium17   15   
Saudi Arabia18   17   
South Korea19   24   
Australia20   20   

Top ranked Finland was selected for its across the board strength in all categories, particularly innovation and labour market efficiency. Singapore ranks second for strength in all categories highlighted by its public and private institutions. Finland moves up one position to third, propelled by strength in health and primary education as well as higher education and training. The US fell from fifth to seventh place, due primarily to a lack of macroeconomic stability, the business community's distrust of politicians and critical business attitudes towards public and private institutions and perceived wasteful spending by government.

R$

WEF Canada innovation rankings

IndicatorRank
Capacity for innovation25   
Company spending on R&D26   
University-industry collaboration on R&D15   
Government procurement of advanced technology products47   
Availability of scientists and engineers6   
Patent Cooperation Treaty patent applications21   
Gross domestic product10   
Source: World Economic Forum



Other News






Events For Leaders in
Science, Tech, Innovation, and Policy


Discuss and learn from those in the know at our virtual and in-person events.



See Upcoming Events










You have 1 free article remaining.
Don't miss out - start your free trial today.

Start your FREE trial    Already a member? Log in






Top

By using this website, you agree to our use of cookies. We use cookies to provide you with a great experience and to help our website run effectively in accordance with our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.